VISMAYA: History & Philosophy of Physics

Category: Writers

  • Open access : a few thoughts and books

    I think that knowledge, especially academic knowledge, should be openly accessible to fellow researchers and the public. Given that most of the academic research in India is public-funded, it is imperative that our work is made available for anyone interested in reading and utilizing the knowledge. This makes a strong case for making our work open to access. Unfortunately, the open-access publication venture has been hijacked by some commercial publishers, who have misused the enthusiasm of academic researchers by converting it into a money-making opportunity via so-called ‘gold’ open-access models, where authors pay exorbitant article processing charges (APCs) to publish their work in the journals.

    I have been searching literature to understand the philosophy and economics of open-access publishing models, and recently, by chance, I came across a couple of books by Peter Suber.

    First is an open-access book on Open Access. Peter Suber has been a philosopher & open-access advocate for a long time. In this book, he explains what it really means to have open access to knowledge & the related philosophy, including its economics. Link to the book.

    Second is a collection of writings on open-access publication (link), and as the online blurb says :

    Influential writings make the case for open access to research, explore its implications, and document the early struggles and successes of the open access movement.

    The green open-access model is very interesting and pertinent to countries such as India, and as per wiki it is defined as :

    Green OA, is the practice of placing a version of an author’s manuscript into a repository, making it freely accessible for the scientific community.

    The primary motivation of Open Access was
    to provide Open Access to Knowledge to the READER of Publications and; to allow Open Access to AUTHORS Publication (unbiased publication of Knowledge)

    Open access in the true sense, should neither have barriers to knowledge consumption nor to knowledge generation and dissemination. Therefore, APCs are a major hurdle to researchers and authors who do not have monetary support. This is most of the global south, and hence, a fair policy is needed to make it more democratic.

  • Why write interesting papers ?

    A lesson I keep learning from Daan Frenkel: write interesting research papers. Thanks to Arghya Dutta (on X), who brought the paper below to my notice. https://arxiv.org/abs/1211.4440

    Sometimes, interesting, well-written papers can have a deeper impact. Even otherwise, it would add clarity.

    Scholarship + interesting writing >>>> prestige of the journal.

    Don’t worship journals.

    A common question when I say so is: what about academic assessment for jobs and promotion?

    My answer is that academia (still) values consistent, scholarly output in reasonable journals.

    It is very hard to reject scholarship. Aim for this as it is under your control.

  • Asimov on lasers

    Isaac Asimov is undoubtedly one of the greatest science fiction writer in English. He also wrote a lot of non-fiction science books that are interesting and accurate in their exposition. I recently came across an interesting book by him on lasers. Written around 1990s, this book discusses the origins of lasers and the basic physics and engineering aspects of lasers. True to his reputation, he weaves interesting history into the science, that makes an engaging read. Some grayscale (charcoal-kind) illustrations in the book are appealing, and makes it a smooth read.

    The book also has a short discussion on applications of lasers, and eye surgery is one of them which is explained lucidly.

    If you are not from a scientific background, or want to have a light read on lasers, then I would recommend this book. As usual, Asimov does not disappoint you !

    Asimov was a biochemistry professor before he became a full time writer. His incliniation towards chemistry is evident when he discusses ‘chemical laser’. I reproduce a couple of paragraphs from his book:

    This idea of the so called ‘chemical laser’ is still under exploration, and has not found its full potential. Perhaps there is an interesting research problem here for the interested.

    Internet archives has a link to this book, but it is not complete. On the internet, you may find other links to this book.

    What was surprising to me is that I found a Marathi translation of this book online. I don’t know how good is the translation, but I will urge you check it out if you know the language well.

    Asimov was a unique person, as he blended science, storytelling and writing very efficiently. We need more of his kind in this world.

  • Tweet on Asimov

  • Conversation with Biman Nath

    Biman Nath is a cosmologist and a Professor at Raman Research Institute, Bengaluru

    His webpage : https://wwws.rri.res.in/~biman/

    He is also bi-lingual author (non-fiction+fiction)

    We discuss

    • his bio, growing up in Assam, career trajectory in India & US, his research, books, writing process ++
    • his current research interest in cosmology especially related to diffuse gases and deliberated on some contemporary questions.
    • on a variety of books he has authored and what motivated him to write in Bengali and English. What has been his experience in communicating science in two different languages.
    • many other topics including a segment in Bengali

    Listen, as we humanize science…

    Youtube audio :

    spotify :

    google podcast : https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9hbmNob3IuZm0vcy9lMTcyMGUwYy9wb2RjYXN0L3Jzcw/episode/N2VjMWUxNWEtYWY5NS00ZjUwLWI1MWEtZGJkYmNlZmY1Y2Q3?sa=X&ved=0CAUQkfYCahcKEwjo4tnWgbiBAxUAAAAAHQAAAAAQAQ

    apple podcast : https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-21-conversation-with-biman-nath-cosmologist-bi/id1687861465?i=1000628507584

    References :

    1. “Biman B. Nath.” Accessed September 9, 2023. https://wwws.rri.res.in/~biman/.
    2. “Biman B. Nath | Raman Research Institute.” Accessed September 9, 2023. https://www.rri.res.in/people/faculty/biman-b-nath.
    3. “‪Biman B. Nath‬ – ‪Google Scholar‬.” Accessed September 9, 2023. https://scholar.google.co.in/citations?user=yQa01BoAAAAJ&hl=en.
    4. Amazon.In.” Accessed September 9, 2023. https://www.amazon.in/Books-Biman-Nath/s?rh=n%3A976389031%2Cp_27%3ABiman+Nath.
    5. “International Astronomical Union | IAU.” Accessed September 9, 2023. https://www.iau.org/administration/membership/individual/427/.
    6. Nath, Biman. Homi J Bhabha: A Renaissance Man among Scientists. Niyogi Books Pvt. Ltd., 2022.
    7. Nath, Biman. Solar System in Verse. Niyogi Books India Private Limited, 2023.
    8. Nath, Biman B. The Dawn of the Universe. Universities Press, 2005.
    9. Nath, Biman. The Story of Helium and the Birth of Astrophysics. 2013th edition. Springer, 2012.
    10. Similarities Between Sanskrit and Lithuanian, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzRxSVK7qIU.
    11. “Ibn Al-Haytham.” In Wikipedia, September 6, 2023. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ibn_al-Haytham&oldid=1174142032.
  • Austin Kleon – inspirations

    Austin Kleon on Writing, Creativity and The Importance of Idleness, 2020. https://open.spotify.com/episode/33TUAo3iWBbSolsf08q3FJ.

    I found the discussion in this podcast interesting. Austin Kleon is charting out some interesting intellectual territory, and his work and thoughts are worth following. I have read most of his books and seen his talks, and it resonates with combinatoric creativity that Maria Popova often writes about.

    Will Durant is quoted to have said – “nothing is new, except the arrangement”

  • Chandra quoting Milne..

    One of my all time fav. quotes. Chandra got it from Milne. Chandra had great temperament for scholarly work, & one can learn a lot from his style of working. His biographer, KC Wali, was a particle physicist, & his article linked is worth reading: https://jstor.org/stable/24100199

    If interested, you can listen to a podcast I did on Chandra (one of the two of the similar name)…

  • Some ironies of publishing

    Some ironies of publishing:
    a) An open access paper highlighted by a paywalled news article
    b) Journal coverpage is a highlight paid by the author to the journal (many ppl don’t know this)
    c) most of the Journal coverpages are designed by the authors at their own cost

  • A thread on photography

  • Link to essays on Oppenheimer

    Linked below is a fantastic, well researched & authentic biographical sketch of Oppenheimer – through a series of essays by Ashutosh Jogalekar

    The movie has created a hype, and in India, people have taken interest for various reasons.

    At the core – Oppenheimer was a scientist, in true spirit.