VISMAYA: History & Philosophy of Physics

Category: History

  • Sakal Lit Fest – a few snaps

    On 12th Nov 2026, I had a wonderful conversation with Ram Ramaswamy
    on Kosambi(s) and the book, as part of Sakal Lit Fest, at BORI, Pune. Below are a few snaps of the session.

    The day started with a keynote address by Banu Mushtaq. It was wonderful to listen to her live.

    What a storyteller…She took something mundane about her travels (pre- and post-Booker) and eventually revealed why ‘no story is small’. I was amazed by her self-deprecating sense of humor, and how seamlessly she wove a story out of her observations.

    The theme of “No story is small” resonates well with scientific pursuits in an age where the impact and the impact factor of a journal are used as substitutes. This talk reminded me of how something specific and local can turn into a universal message; a lesson we often learn in the pursuit of scientific research.

    Some may say two cultures, but I think we have common roots.

  • Feynman’s way..

    “In an interview filmed just a few weeks before his death, Richard Feynman described his search for Tannu Tuva. Tannu Tuva was a small country in Asia, now part of the Soviet Union, known in the West primarily for its triangular postage stamps. Feynman wanted to visit Tannu Tuva, but didn’t want to take advantage of his reputation as a Nobel Prize-winning physicist. He wanted to do it, as he put it, “in the right way.” His efforts to arrange a visit spanned several years. In the process he learned to write Tuvan and became familiar with Tuvan singing. Feynman’s invitation to Tannu Tuva arrived two weeks after his death. Science is like Feynman’s quest. The most important thing is to do it “in the right way.””

    Quoted from the preface of the book: Franklin, Allan. Experiment, Right or Wrong. Cambridge University Press, 2008.

  • Mathematical notations and Leibniz handwriting

    I recently came across an interesting interview in Quanta magazine with David E. Dunning, a historian of mathematics. In it, John Pavlus and Dunning discuss the relevance of notation in mathematical writing and how it has led to the evolution of ideas. One of the pictures that caught my attention was an image of Leibniz’s handwritten paper on calculus, as seen below.

    Image credit: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Bibliothek/Stephen Wolfram/Public Domain

    Dunning mentions how mathematical symbolism in calculus led to the spread of some of the notations that we are familiar with today (such as dy/dx), and contrasts the methods of Newton and Leibniz. He mentions that “Newton understood his calculus to be much more rooted in geometry than Leibniz did.” Whereas “Leibniz wanted a much more algebraic, symbolic, notation-focused calculus.”

    There is also a pertinent discussion related to numerals (Hindu-Arabic vis-à-vis Roman variety). Overall, a good read if you are interested in the history of science/mathematics.

    Reference:

    Pavlus, John. ‘How Writing Changes Mathematical Thought’. Quanta Magazine, 25 March 2026. https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-writing-changes-mathematical-thought-20260325/.

  • Conversation with Suneeta Vardarajan

    Suneeta Vardarajan is a Professor of Physics at IISER Pune, working in gravitation and mathematical physics. Her group studies black holes, from classical perturbation theory, which helps identify astrophysical signatures of black holes, to their quantum features. In this episode, we discuss the research questions she has been interested in over the years and her ability to effectively combine research with teaching and science communication.

    References:

    ‘Sites.Iiserpune.Ac.in/~suneeta/’. Accessed 3 October 2026. https://sites.iiserpune.ac.in/%7Esuneeta/.

    ‘Suneeta Vardarajan’. Accessed 3 October 2026. https://www.iiserpune.ac.in/research/department/physics/people/faculty/regular-faculty/suneeta-vardarajan/350.

    ‘Vardarajan Suneeta – INSPIRE’. Accessed 3 October 2026. https://inspirehep.net/authors/987127.

    SMC_IISER Pune. Beyond Darkness | Public Lecture Programme on Black Holes | IISER Pune. 2026. 02:08:09. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_N3PFMUxPc.

    srijit bhattacharjee. Suneeta Vardarajan: Recent Developments in Semi-Classical Gravity. 2024. 01:05:22. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHvSO1YT6tY.

    Vardarajan, Suneeta. Non-Euclidean Geometry. 1584457087. 880. https://www.ted.com/talks/suneeta_vardarajan_non_euclidean_geometry.

    X (Formerly Twitter). ‘(1) Suneeta Vardarajan (@Ms_Gravitas) / X’. 26 July 2026. https://x.com/ms_gravitas.

  • Perhaps…truth..

    Perhaps it is not a question of truth, but it is the reaction to the truth. Perhaps it is not the feeling of the truth, but the consequence of knowing that truth can be so deep and yet can reach so far. Perhaps truth, which is generally considered slow, can intrigue our minds and revisit us instantaneously.

    Is there anything called ‘the truth’? The truth itself may look like a transient, but again, the question remains: Is truth so important? A scientist, an artist, a curious mind is in search of truth, in their own way. The vocabulary, the picture, and the question may have textures and different forms, but there is a strange kind of unity in the pursuit of the truth. A human life is perhaps worth living and perhaps worth pursuing in the pursuit of this truth. Perhaps that is the lesson. We need to relearn, unlearn, and teach ourselves that truth matters for humanity.

    As we search for truth, peace, and knowledge, we realize that none of these is independent of the others. Perhaps a few human beings in the history of humankind have made an attempt to attain the ‘truth’. They don’t remain with us, but the pursuit remains. Perhaps humans are transient, and truth is a constant. Perhaps…that is a truth.

  • Astronomy in Africa: Who is studying it?

    Africa and Africans have had rich knowledge about astronomy. The authors of a recent paper on arXiv explore some interesting issues of where that knowledge comes from and who is exploring it.

    The abstract reads:

    Africa has deep and diverse traditions of astronomical knowledge, ranging from archaeological astronomy, pharaonic stellar timekeeping, and manuscript astronomy in Timbuktu and the Sahel, to ecological seasonal astronomy in southern Africa and calendrical computation in the Ethiopian tradition. These multiple epistemic traditions form part of a long intellectual history that precedes and intersects with contemporary astronomy on the continent. In the context of this long-standing intellectual heritage, an important question arises regarding the contemporary circulation of African astronomical knowledge within the global scientific system. This study therefore examines where African astronomical knowledge is produced, validated, and circulated in modern scholarly communication. Using bibliometric data from the Web of Science Core Collection, our analysis investigates publication and citation patterns in the research area Astronomy and Astrophysics between 2000 and 2025, with particular attention to the publication venues of African scholars. The findings highlight a critical paradox: while African researchers are active contributors to global astronomical discovery, the intellectual capital generated through this work is largely stored, validated, and circulated through publication systems located outside the continent. This pattern reflects broader asymmetries within global scholarly communication, where dominant publishing infrastructures shape visibility, citation impact, and authority. By applying a decolonial lens to metrics such as citation impact and ownership, the paper calls for a critical reassessment of the academic practices that sustain epistemic coloniality. It concludes that achieving scientific equity requires a strategic shift in publication choices to build and fortify a sovereign African knowledge archive.

    There are some impressive snapshots of old manuscripts. An example is shown below:

    There are many more interesting points in the manuscript. Check it out.

    Reference to the paper:

    Koch, Rhea, and Amare Abebe. ‘From Timbuktu to SKA: Who Owns the Astronomy Knowledge Africa Produces?’ arXiv:2608.21119. Preprint, arXiv, 21 August 2026. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2608.21119.

  • The Controversial Schrödinger

    12th of August is Erwin Schrödinger’s birthday…. Although he has been one of the pioneers of quantum mechanics (of the cat fame) and has contributed deeply to the subject matter, in recent years, he has become (in)famous for his non-academic life. For sure, he had a controversial personal life and has been deservedly criticized for that.

    Only recently, there has been some new archival information (see this) that throws more light on this and gives some benefit of the doubt.

    An important lesson: Great science alone does not guarantee good human qualities in a scientist.

    ps:

    To paraphrase and expand on something I wrote recently –

    We continue to celebrate science by a person because science is not only of that person, but of humanity….

    A person learns from others, transforms it and passes it on.

    The human mind is both a conduit and a seed of an idea. Lest we forget the soil, sunshine, water and air.