VISMAYA: History & Philosophy of Physics

Category: History

  • My Forward Moving Chakra

    In 1980s, every Friday morning, Akaashvani Bengaluru (a local radio channel of the state; language Kannada) woke me up with Bhimsen Joshi’s famous rendition – Bhaagyada laxmi baaramma. This song has stayed with me and somehow makes me nostalgic for the times we lived – a simple, lower-middle-class life. More than the devotional undertone of this song, what captured my attention was how it was beautifully adapted in a movie by Shankar Nag without compromising its authenticity. It showed me how art can be inclusive yet distinct.

    I went to a local private English school. Those were the times when school education was affordable even for a lower-income family like ours, and now, if I look back, I did get a relatively decent primary education. Some of the teachers I remember had names: Firdoos, Christy and Geeta. 

    An interesting aspect of my upbringing was my exposure to various sports. It included cricket (of course), cycling, eye-spies, lagori, buguri, goli and bachha. The last three sports are unique. Buguri is playing with a top, where you spin the top with a tied rope. By releasing the rope skillfully, one can make the top rotate at a location of interest, be it on the floor or in the palm of your hand. 

    Goli is playing with marbles, where you compete with an opponent by hitting a marble with another. There were several games within the umbrella of this fascinating meta-game, and it was one of the most competitive sports I have played. 

    Bachha will be the most unfamiliar sport to many of you reading. It was typically played by children who grew up in lower-middle income surroundings, and the game was to use well-polished granite slabs that can fit your hand. This was made to sail over a tar road. The sailing of the stone had to be smooth, and the target of this throw was to dislodge a pile of old cigarette carrying paper boxes (without cigarettes) that had been collected over a long period of time. The whole point of the game was to hit the piled-up packs of these folded boxes and win them as a collection. Different boxes of cigarette brands had different values. Talk about capitalism !

    Through the 1990s, the teenage years were memorable. Riding a two-wheeled motor vehicle made you feel you had evolved into an adult. It gave you the freedom to go to a petrol bunk and fill up the tank full of fuel (with tinge of kerosene) on a gear(care)less TVS 50. The picture that has stayed with me is the skilful handling of a bunch of currency notes by the guys who filled the petrol. They used to double up as cashiers (as they do even now), but then everything was to be dealt in cash, and the human processing speeds had to be good. Similar skills were evident with BTS bus conductors. A fascinating thing about them was that they had a whistle. This made their presence felt, and they were the representatives of the unique city culture of Bangalore. Their images are so iconic that many Kannada movies then had bus conductors as characters of their movies. Rajnikanth was one of the early ones to play this role. And yes, he started in Kannada movies, as did a few other Tamil superstars.

    Deccan Herald was and is a newspaper that most of the Bengalurians are aware of. It had some wonderful commentaries on history and geography. Thanks to some of these articles by well-known writers, I was interested in these subjects. I was so motivated and encouraged by them that, as a school kid, I wrote them a letter. They published it. I remember it was a Saturday, and I spent my whole weekend staring at my article on paper. It was also a time when I learned about the great H. Narasimiaha distributing puffed rice to local people during a solar eclipse. His writings and thoughts sowed the seeds of rationality in me. Gradually, I transformed into an atheist, and over the years, I have adapted compassionate rationality as a way of living and thinking. This way has allowed me to appreciate my culture’s deep roots without compromising on rational thinking. It has given me a balance.

    What was out of balance in my life was the pressure of education. The worst part of the late 90s was my pre-university education. Then, 11 and 12-grade education was part of pre-university college, and this exposed one to a life of partial independence. Unlike a bachelor’s degree, this time in college is boring, and everything is done to crack some silly exams that have ‘not so silly’ consequences on one’s career. With great fortune, I escaped a turbulent time and found myself doing BSc (Physics, Maths, Electronics), with a healthy amount of languages, including Sanskrit and English. Throughout this period, the wonderful libraries across the city were central to my education. There were many old public libraries in Bangalore, and one did not need any membership to read a book. I saw so many people preparing for civil service exams in such libraries. 

    In 2000s, I fell in love with physics. Astrophysics gripped my life and took me through an intellectual journey that has not stopped ever since. Intellectual pursuits are that way. One can vaguely remember their origins, but one will realize the effect on one’s life only after a while. Interestingly, it changes the character of a person. That is the power of education. 

    I went to Bangalore University to do my Masters in physics. This state-funded university’s semester fees were less than present-day woodland shoes. For the first time, I saw how education can be aspirational, inspirational, political, liberating, suffocating and fun. All at once. This was also the time I discovered that economics and politics have far-reaching consequences in scientific research. 

    This was also the era of my PhD at JNCASR. I started as a serious student of physics and ended my PhD as a serious student of science. This was transformative not only because I was exposed to new knowledge but also because I could contribute to knowledge. At the end of the first year of my PhD, I got an excellent opportunity to travel to the US. I attended a summer school at University of California, Santa Barbara.

    Interestingly, this journey was the first time I took a flight on an aeroplane, and the trajectory was long and interesting as I flew around the globe (Bangalore to Bangkok to Osaka to Los Angeles) thanks to the limited funding. The biggest realization of my arrival in LA was a massive billboard of an iconic iPod silhouette advertisement. It is etched in my inner eye. My first travel within the US was a road trip from LA to Santa Barbara. What a ride!

    After I finished my PhD, I moved to Barcelona and lived in Castelldefels. I shared my apartment with an Uruguayan (Spanish: uruguayos) couple and a cute dog. It was interesting that we were all immigrants. They spoke Spanish, but I did not, which impacted how we assimilated into the society. Although we did not speak similar languages, we could communicate very well with each other. That was an interesting lesson for me. 

    Then I moved to the US, and this was a time when Obama had just been elected into office. I have never seen a country undergoing economic recession and yet was so enthusiastic politically as the US. The ‘Yes We Can’ was an iconic campaign; I could see how it touched so many lives in the US. It was also a time when I was exposed to American professionalism and their excellent work culture. This has deeply impacted my thinking and how I look at work. It also made me realize the (positive and negative) powers of a free market economy. Again, it was an education.

    In 2010, I got married, and started looking at life from a slightly long-term perspective. At the cusp of the decade, I moved back to India, and this time to Pune. Culturally, this is one of the wealthiest places in India. The flux of thought is high, and the people you get exposed to is often fascinating. It was also a time when I was building my lab, and I found how essential teamwork is. You always realize this when you are doing your PhD, but when you set up your group, you get a different grasp of how highly educated humans behave and coordinate for the greater good with a common goal.

    Interestingly, these common goals can also align with personal career goals and growth. From a close quarter, I see how five years of focused work can transform people’s lives and thoughts. We need to pay more attention to the long-term work.

    One of my life moments was to see my wife delivering my daughter. It made me feel human. I was there in that ward beside my wife, and those few minutes has transformed me forever. It also made me realize the power of human bonds. The day’s images are etched in my memory, and I thank biology for all that! 

    Now, we are in 2020s, and the pandemic has eaten away a few years. The early years also led to an explosion of information, and understanding the world is a continued challenge. An astonishing aspect has been that we, as humans, are still fighting wars. It indicates that we still do not understand each other, and cooperation is still a major goal to achieve. More work to do.

    Ashoka Chakra. Image courtesy : link

       All through this journey, what has remained with me is reading, writing and talking to people. All people from all walks of life. Writing and talking has also encouraged me to use them as tools to look at the world. A lesson that I derive from all this: human cultures should use knowledge from the past and present and move towards the future. A forward-looking culture distills the best from every cultural exposure and adapts them to move forward. This is also a lesson from evolutionary biology, and perhaps a lesson for a beautiful country like India, that is Bharat, and many other magnificent things.

    We are the people, and the wheel – the chakra, represents us on the move. This is the life I want to travel on : riding on a chakra of a forward-looking culture. 

  • Robert Boyle’s project list

    More than 300 years ago, Robert Boyle made a wish list of research projects, and some of them are still relevant and interesting. Below is the list reproduced from archives of Royal society

  • S.N. Bose in Rajya Sabha

    Any physics buff would know Bose-Einstein condensation and the statistics named after them. An interesting fact is Satyendra Nath Bose (SN Bose) also served as a member of the Indian parliament. 

    SN Bose was a member of the Rajya Sabha. Notably, he participated in some debates on bills, mainly in the second term, circa 1955 onwards. He was part of the earliest formulation of THE UNIVERSITY GRANTS COMMISSION BILL, 1954. See this link for the bills in which he was involved.

    On page 95 of brief biographies of Rajya Sabha members, you will find the following information (snapshot below). These documents are freely available on the Rajya Sabha website and are worth exploring.

    Bose also participated in some debates in the Rajya Sabha, mainly regarding education/research. 

    Below is an excerpt of his speech related to UGC bill, and shows his interest in the then university/academic system of India (emphasis added) :

      It has, of course, been suggested that this particular Commission would be able to solve the problem of education in this country. I may, however, point out that in this task we will ultimately have to depend upon the responsible people that are in charge of education inside the Universities. I also know, Sir, that every teacher in our country is alive to his responsibility, and the corporate bodies that we have set up in our land are also serious about their tasks. I do not feel, Sir, that the standard of our universities has gone down to a very ludicrous level. I do not feel so, because I remember the long list of persons that have been turned out by these universities who had served the national cause, and who have been and who still continue to be the leaders of thought in our country. We also remember. Sir, that in many of these universities, there are young people and workers who have achieved fame and distinction, who have contributed substantially to the cause of learning, and who have made the name of India respected in different lands. Therefore, Sir, you need not have any misgivings about the way in which, work is being done in our universities. All that is wanted is that you should be generous, and you should set up an efficient machinery  which should be able to get in touch with the people who work at different centres, and should find out what they need. And you should be able to supply those needs in the form of grants, which may either be given out of the Consolidated Fund of the Government or out of the fund set apart for this purpose, which would be administered by the Commission. 

    As you can observe, SN Bose is making a case for increased funding to the Indian research community and is emphasizing the availability of excellent human resources in universities. As researchers in India, we must ask ourselves whether we have lived up to his confidence and effectively addressed these issues over the past several decades. I believe we have not. Bose’s optimism motivates us to relook at our system and self-reflect on pursuing scientific and technological research in India. A good starting point is to ask for ‘ease of doing research and teaching’. 

    A few Indian scientists of the past, including Meghnad Saha and MGK Menon, were also members of the Indian parliament. Still, this representation needs to be improved, as discussed by my colleague MS Santhanam. Scientists inclined to take politics to influence society must openly express their opinions on policies related to science and technology. If they do get elected to the office, it is their imperative to actively participate in parliamentary debates and ask and address relevant questions, especially about education and research.

    After all, the foundation of democracy is based on ‘questions and answers’, and interestingly, that is also the foundation of scientific method.

  • Story of Eric Betzig

    I narrate a short, peculiar career story of Eric Betzig..one of the scientists behind super-resolution optical microscope

  • Tables turned…I was a guest on a podcast

    IndiaBiosciences Podcast has a series on science podcasters.

    The link to the episode on IndiaBiosciences webpage is here.

    For this one, the tables turned..and it was a delight to converse with @Arushi_Batra28 on her podcast on a fascinating series on science podcasters.. Great initiative by @IndiaBioscience wonderfully led by @_KarishmaK

  • Excerpt from Isaacson’s interview

    photo : wikicommons

    Walter Isaacson is a legendary biographer who has written great books on Einstein, Leonardo, Doudna, Jobs, Musk and many more. His work is remarkable because he blends depth and breath very efficiently. Recently, I came across an interview of his, and the below excerpt is worth reading :

    HUMANITIES: For Einstein, you had to grapple with a large number of very technical subjects, and various language barriers, but still produced a generously sized and highly readable book about the most famous physicist of the twentieth century. How do you get so much work done, while also punching in at the office?

    ISAACSON: I don’t watch TV. If you give up TV, it’s amazing how many hours there are between 7:00 p.m. and 1:00 a.m. in which you can do writing. More importantly, I work with a lot of people, Brian Greene, Murray Gell-Mann, people I knew who were tutoring me in physics.

    When I tackled Einstein, I realized that science is totally beautiful. Nonscientists are often intimidated by it, but it’s not as hard when you can see the beauty in the tensor calculus that Einstein used for general relativity or the beauty in his thought experiments, which help him describe special relativity, gravity, and the curvature of the space-time fabric of the universe. Those are, to me, glorious, beautiful things. An outsider might think, Oh, that’s science and math. Isn’t that difficult? No, science and math can be really beautiful, especially if you have good people helping you learn it.

  • J.C. Bose and the measurement of refractive index

    Image : Wikicommons

    How do you determine the refractive index of a material which is not transparent?

    In 1895, J.C. Bose addressed this question experimentally using ‘electric rays’, which we currently know as microwave radiation!

    The citation of the paper is

    Bose, J. C., I. On the determination of the indices of refraction of various substances for the electric ray. I. Index of refraction of sulphur. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, 59(353–358), 160–167. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspl.1895.0069

    Below is the title of the paper that was communicated to the Royal Society via Lord Rayleigh, who was an authority on optical concepts Bose was using.

    His experiment used the microwaves’ total internal reflection and extracted the samples’ refractive index through Brewster’s angle.

    Bose beautifully describes his method as follows :

    The angle of incidence is slowly decreased till the critical value is reached. At this point the ray is all at once refracted into the air, making an angle of 90° with the normal to the surface. If a receiver be fixed against the side of the semi-cylinder at II, it will now respond to the refracted radiation.

    Below is the diagram depicting the same principle :

    And the detailed description is as follows:

    The refracting substance is cut out or cast in the form of a semi¬ cylinder, and mounted on the central table of a spectrometer; the electric ray is directed towards the centre of the spectrometer, and its direction is always kept fixed. It strikes the curved surface and passes into its mass without any deviation. It is then incident on the plane surface of the semi-cylinder, and is refracted into the air beyond.

    The apparatus design was also interesting, and the diagram below depicts what we nowadays call the microwave transmitter (indicated as radiator, R) and receiver (indicated as Coherer, C).

    If you read the paper completely, the details of experiments are described meticulously, and the attention to detail is remarkable.

    So, he determines the refractive index of sulfur using this method and ends up with a value of 1.734, which is quite accurate even by today’s standards (the value is upwards of 1.7 and depends on the wavelength of light). Notice that the measurement was made to the accuracy of three decimal places, which is impressive. Below is a set of data for which the value of the refractive index was determined.

    Now compare this to the modern measurement (see below data from around 1985) of refractive index based on more sophisticated methods, and you will see the matching is reasonably good at higher wavelengths close to 1 micron. (Note that Bose’s measurements was at higher wavelength than shown below)

    Data from: Icarus. Volume 64, Issue 3, December 1985, Pages 368-374; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0019103585900612

    J.C. Bose was a creative scientist; the above example is just a small illustration of his capabilities as an experimentalist.

    Now, with this inspiration, let me head back to my lab to do some experiments :-)

    ps: A video to go with this blog (updated on 17th Apr 2025)

  • Electron Microscopy and Optical Holography: some notes from history

    Since the 16th century CE, improving the limits of optical resolution has become an essential technical goal in optics research, and it continues to challenge us even today. When they were introduced, optical microscopes opened a new world for humans to observe, learn and eventually control matter at microscopic scales. A logical progression in this thought was to extend the resolution limit to the atomic scales unavailable to optical microscopes. Enter the ‘electron’ microscope. They changed the game entirely and paved the way to visualize matter at the atomic scale.

    Electron microscopes were invented in the 1930s. When they were built in some laboratories, there was considerable public interest in understanding these “advanced” tools, as witnessed by a short but interesting article in the September 1940 edition of Popular Mechanics.

    Sept 1940: Above is an image and description of one of the earliest electron microscopes published in Popular Mechanics

    Reference: Popular Mechanics ~ 1940. n.d. Accessed January 7, 2024. http://archive.org/details/PopularMechanics1940.

    The article speculates

    First applications of the electron microscope are expected to be in biological and industrial research.

    This is interesting because electron microscopes were still in their infancy, and the working principles were explored for better quality images and sample durability.

    The origins of the electron microscope have an interesting history and were inspired by optics (for an interesting commentary, see Freundlich, Martin M. 1963. “Origin of the Electron Microscope.” Science 142 (3589): 185–88. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1712183). The first demonstration of a working microscope was by Ruska and Knoll (Z. Tech. Phys., 12 (1931)), and the conceptual foundations date back to the late 1890s. Ruska was eventually awarded a Nobel prize for his work on electron optics and the invention of the electron microscope in 1986.

    As with any development in science and technology, an idea becomes a seed to another idea. In the case of electron microscopy, it led to some early motivations behind the invention of optical holography by Dennis Gabor, which eventually fetched him a Nobel Prize in 1970.

    Dennis Gabor was also inspired and interested by the invention of electron microscopes. He played a critical role in formulating the problem of resolution limit, which further led to the invention of holography. To quote his Nobel lecture :

    Let us now jump a century and a half, to 1947. At that time I was very
    interested in electron microscopy. This wonderful instrument had at that time
    produced a hundredfold improvement on the resolving power of the best light
    microscopes, and yet it was disappointing, because it had stopped short of resolving atomic lattices. The de Broglie wavelength of fast electrons, about
    l/20 Ångström, was short enough, but the optics was imperfect. The best
    electron objective which one can make can be compared in optical perfection
    to a raindrop than to a microscope objective, and through the theoretical
    work of O. Scherzer it was known that it could never be perfected.

    Interestingly, Gabor started his work in Germany but had to move out of the country due to the political situation. As he mentions in his biographical note :

    In 1933, when Hitler came to power, I left Germany and after a short period in Hungary went to England. At that time, in 1934, England was still in the depths of the depression, and jobs for foreigners were very difficult. I obtained employment with the British Thomson-Houston Co., Rugby, on an inventor’s agreement. The invention was a gas discharge tube with a positive characteristic, which could be operated on the mains.

    He stayed back in England and continued his work. The important aspect is that the development of electron microscopy eventually led to some fundamental experiments in optical holography. To quote Gabor’s biographical note :

    The years after the war were the most fruitful. I wrote, among many others, my first papers on communication theory, I developed a system of stereoscopic cinematography, and in the last year, 1948 I carried out the basic experiments in holography, at that time called “wavefront reconstruction”. This again was an exercise in serendipity. The original objective was an improved electron microscope, capable of resolving atomic lattices and seeing single atoms. Three year’s work, 1950-53, carried out in collaboration with the AEI Research Laboratory in Aldermaston, led to some respectable results, but still far from the goal. We had started 20 years too early. 

    The general notion in optics is that experiments in the visible light frequencies led to developments in electron microscopy. In the case of optical holography, at least in the initial stages of its invention, electron microscopy played a critical role. Developments in electron optics led to some fundamental questions in optical wavefront reconstruction. This further led to optical holography.

    This reminds me of a quote attributed to Buckminster :

    How often I found where I should be going only by setting out for somewhere else.

  • Mind, Pen & Paper – starting a video series

    A series that I had always wanted to create. Here is the first one.

  • A capitalistic Galileo ?